MyBestGuide
MyBestGuide
Websites & Digital Growth
June 2024 10 min read

Website Looks Fine, but Isn’t Working? Start With These Checks

Your website may look professional, but that doesn’t automatically mean it is helping your business grow. Use these diagnostic checks before a redesign.

Website Looks Fine, but Isn’t Working? Start With These Checks
Imagine someone visits your business website after discovering your company through Google, social media or a recommendation. The website looks professional. The images are attractive, the colours are consistent, and the homepage appears well-designed. But after spending a few seconds looking around, the visitor leaves. They don't contact you, request a quotation or explore your services. If this sounds familiar, you may be wondering whether your website needs a complete redesign. Not necessarily. A website can look visually appealing while still making it difficult for visitors to understand your business, find the information they need or take the next step. Before spending money on a new website, check whether your existing one is communicating clearly, working properly and making it easy for visitors to become customers. This guide walks you through eight practical checks to help identify where your website may need improvement.

1. Check Whether Your Website Clearly Explains What You Offer

Your homepage has an important responsibility: helping visitors understand your business. When someone lands on your website for the first time, they should be able to answer three basic questions: what does this business offer, who are its services or products intended for, and what should I do next? If visitors have to search through multiple sections to understand what you actually do, your messaging may need improvement. Look at the first section visitors see when opening your homepage and review the main headline, supporting text, visuals, and call to action.

2. Test Your Website on a Mobile Phone

A website that looks excellent on a desktop screen may provide a frustrating experience on a smartphone. Visitors may struggle with small text, overlapping elements, difficult navigation or buttons that are uncomfortable to tap. Don't assume your website is mobile-friendly simply because it opens on a phone. Open your website on an actual smartphone and go through the main visitor journey, paying attention to readability and ease of interaction.

3. Review Your Website Loading Speed

Visitors shouldn't have to wait unnecessarily for important website content to appear. Slow-loading pages can interrupt the browsing experience, especially when someone is accessing your website through a mobile connection. Performance also affects how search engines evaluate your site. Use tools like Google PageSpeed Insights to monitor metrics like Largest Contentful Paint (LCP).

4. Examine Your Website Navigation

Navigation should make the website feel straightforward rather than like a puzzle. Watch out for too many menu items, unclear page names, or important services hidden inside complex menus. Try viewing your website as someone who knows nothing about your business. Can they reach the information they need without repeatedly going back and forth?

5. Test Every Important Button and Link

A button can look perfect and still fail to perform its intended job. Create a simple functionality checklist to verify that your logo links back home, navigation links open correctly, contact buttons work, and forms submit successfully. Don't assume something works just because it looks clickable.

6. Make Your Enquiry Forms Easy to Complete

An unnecessarily complicated enquiry form can make it harder for visitors to contact you. Reduce unnecessary fields, use clear labels, and provide useful validation messages. Test the complete process to confirm that enquiries actually reach the intended email address or connected system.

7. Check Whether Your Website Builds Trust

Trust isn't created by attractive graphics alone. Visitors need relevant information that supports their decision. Review these elements: About Us details, clear service descriptions, a relevant portfolio, contact information, and genuine testimonials.

8. Review Website Performance Data

A page that looks fine to you may still have usability or conversion problems that aren't immediately obvious. Start with Google Search Console to see clicks and impressions, and use website analytics to understand which pages receive the most engagement and where visitors exit.

Common Questions

Need a technical audit of your existing site? Let's talk.